Tekin, Castle or Holmes and at which Kv

[BigBlock454]

So I've read through dozens of threads, many close to my question but I'm still a bit grey. I am new to the hobby since November of 2019 and currently have 2 rigs now.

I purchased a Redcat Everest 10 to see of I liked crawling which I love but also don't have alot of local areas to use for this application.

Next I bought the Losi Rock Rey for a Basher/Crawler that I could use in the back yard and when we go camping.

The stock motor cogs bad at low speed so I want to upgrade to a Sensorded Brushless system. I am happy with the factory top speed and power with the Dynamite 2800kv motor running 2s but would not go slower. I would like something very close to the same speed but not slower and also would like to keep the same battery life hopefully with the new system if possible.

Options thus far paired with Mamba X ESC

Holmes Hobbies 3500kv
Tekin Roc 412 3100kv
Castle Creations 2850kv

Question is how much faster would the HH 3500kv be and also how much would it decrease my battery life compared to my stock 2800kv? Also which motor would you recommend? I will be using mostly for trails and back yard fun but would like the ability to do some slower crawling when I find a spot for it.

 

[midwest_rippa]

holmes 3500 is my chouce. most powerful motor not just because of the kv but because holmes uses bigger and stringer magnets. how much faster is simply based on ratios. 3500/2800 equals 1.25 so the 3500 will be 125% as fast as your stock motor. you seriously will not be disappointed with it. tekin are also good motors but holmes is my choice. a holmes 540 puller pro is the same power as a 550 roc412. more power for the size and weight. pair it with a mamba x esc

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

 

[Mr. Crawley EC]

So I've read through dozens of threads, many close to my question but I'm still a bit grey. I am new to the hobby since November of 2019 and currently have 2 rigs now.

I purchased a Redcat Everest 10 to see of I liked crawling which I love but also don't have alot of local areas to use for this application.

Next I bought the Losi Rock Rey for a Basher/Crawler that I could use in the back yard and when we go camping.

The stock motor cogs bad at low speed so I want to upgrade to a Sensorded Brushless system. I am happy with the factory top speed and power with the Dynamite 2800kv motor running 2s but would not go slower. I would like something very close to the same speed but not slower and also would like to keep the same battery life hopefully with the new system if possible.

Options thus far paired with Mamba X ESC

Holmes Hobbies 3500kv
Tekin Roc 412 3100kv
Castle Creations 2850kv

Question is how much faster would the HH 3500kv be and also how much would it decrease my battery life compared to my stock 2800kv? Also which motor would you recommend? I will be using mostly for trails and back yard fun but would like the ability to do some slower crawling when I find a spot for it.

Well, the rock rey is not a crawler at all, it’s a pure basher. In that case a high kv motor will work great with a 3S or 4s battery. Sensored brushless motors strain less battery and you will have an rc bullet.
In the case of your crawler, it depends on the gearing, but the Castle 2850kv is very very smooth in low speed crawling and also gives you a very good top speed (if you can find one), I’ve been looking for it for a while with no luck.
Holmes Hobbies also makes really good motors, you can’t go wrong with any of them, Castle or HH. I have use both and I love them.

 

[BigBlock454]

Thanks for the feedback the 125% helps as well. The Holmes Hobbies is what I'm favouring based on other threads and reviews. I had also messaged Holmes Hobbies multiple times but never got responses so I decided to use the forum. I've never changed motors so I don't have any experience with battery life and speed changes with different kv motors. I was hoping Holmes Hobbies would have something around the 3000kv but I only see 2700 then 3500.

 

[BigBlock454]

I know the Rock Rey is not an ideal crawler but I have seen Youtube clips of people still having fun on the rocks with them after adjusting some of the diff fluids etc and adding Sensored systems. It has fairly tall soft tires which should help. I always have my other crawler for the strict crawl sections which I have done a number of upgrades to make better already. In the future I want to buy a Axial Capra, I love the look and way they crawl. Not as scale but that's ok for me. Not alot of competition crawler stuff in my location. Alberta Canada.

 

[Mr. Crawley EC]

I know the Rock Rey is not an ideal crawler but I have seen Youtube clips of people still having fun on the rocks with them after adjusting some of the diff fluids etc and adding Sensored systems. It has fairly tall soft tires which should help. I always have my other crawler for the strict crawl sections which I have done a number of upgrades to make better already. In the future I want to buy a Axial Capra, I love the look and way they crawl. Not as scale but that's ok for me. Not alot of competition crawler stuff in my location. Alberta Canada.

I have a Capra and when you have one the last thing you care about is the scale looks. It’s so much fun!!
I have a Capra, a Toyzuki v2.5 comp build and a very upgraded SCX24. I really like them all but my favorite is the capra by far!

 

[BigBlock454]

I have a Capra and when you have one the last thing you care about is the scale looks. It’s so much fun!!
I have a Capra, a Toyzuki v2.5 comp build and a very upgraded SCX24. I really like them all but my favorite is the capra by far!

Yepp Capra will be my next rig after upgrading my Rock Rey. I already have a list of parts and upgrades I will want for a Capra when I buy one.

 

[BigBlock454]

If I buy a higher channel Transmitter and Receiver can I setup a button or switch to toggle on/off crawler mode or rather drag brake? Using Mamba X ESC.

 

[Mr. Crawley EC]

If I buy a higher channel Transmitter and Receiver can I setup a button or switch to toggle on/off crawler mode or rather drag brake? Using Mamba X ESC.

I have it set for the drag brake with my Flysky GT-5 and Mamba X. Yes you can with te aux channel connector.

 

[Panther6834]

As chance has it, not only do a happen to have all three motors, albeit, in the different vehicles, but all three just happen to be paired with a Mamba X. The Castle I've got in my first Capra (on a 9T pinion, inside a Vitavon aluminum machined transmission housing), built as a "having fun rock/trail crawler". The HH PP is in the second Capra, built as a Class 3 comp crawler (tho, the transmission is an AX10 3-gear, not the Capra trans). As for the ROC412 HD, that's inside my Baja Rey, the "kissin' cousin" of your Rock Rey.

Considering the similarities between the Rock Rey & Baja Rey, as well as what these two vehicles are intended for (they're NOT crawlers, and they're NOT designed to go slow), I truly believe you'll be happiest with the ROC412 HD 3100kV. Granted, I'm running 3S, plus I've beefed up my Baja Rey for hard off-road use under 3S...but, it's the motor best designed for this type of vehicle.

The Castle has more than adequate torque, but where it shines is in its speed. Conversely, the HH PP has more than adequate speed, but the torque is where is shines. The ROC412 HD is what I call "baby bear"...it's 'just right' - it has a really, really good balance between the torque AND speed.


~ More peace, love, laughter, & kindness would make the world a MUCH better place

 

[BigBlock454]

I have it set for the drag brake with my Flysky GT-5 and Mamba X. Yes you can with te aux channel connector.

Perfect! The Flysky GT-5 is also the same as I was already looking at lol

 

[BigBlock454]

As chance has it, not only do a happen to have all three motors, albeit, in the different vehicles, but all three just happen to be paired with a Mamba X. The Castle I've got in my first Capra (on a 9T pinion, inside a Vitavon aluminum machined transmission housing), built as a "having fun rock/trail crawler". The HH PP is in the second Capra, built as a Class 3 comp crawler (tho, the transmission is an AX10 3-gear, not the Capra trans). As for the ROC412 HD, that's inside my Baja Rey, the "kissin' cousin" of your Rock Rey.

Considering the similarities between the Rock Rey & Baja Rey, as well as what these two vehicles are intended for (they're NOT crawlers, and they're NOT designed to go slow), I truly believe you'll be happiest with the ROC412 HD 3100kV. Granted, I'm running 3S, plus I've beefed up my Baja Rey for hard off-road use under 3S...but, it's the motor best designed for this type of vehicle.

The Castle has more than adequate torque, but where it shines is in its speed. Conversely, the HH PP has more than adequate speed, but the torque is where is shines. The ROC412 HD is what I call "baby bear"...it's 'just right' - it has a really, really good balance between the torque AND speed.


~ More peace, love, laughter, & kindness would make the world a MUCH better place

Awesome, muchly appreciate the feedback.

 

[Mr. Crawley EC]

Perfect! The Flysky GT-5 is also the same as I was already looking at lol

Have used it for more than a year now, really really good and very affordable (transmitter and receivers).

 

[BigBlock454]

Thanks everyone so far for the replies. Last question would be on the servo for the Rock Rey.

My top choices are:

Reefs 444
Savox 1210
Hitec 795_

Favor the Reefs because it appears quiet. The Hitec seems to have a constant noise which I don't like. Savox I've seen used alot but unsure if it's as good as the Reefs.

All are difficult to find here in Alberta. Or so it seems thus far. Also alot more money then they are in the US.

 

[Mr. Crawley EC]

Thanks everyone so far for the replies. Last question would be on the servo for the Rock Rey.

My top choices are:

Reefs 444
Savox 1210
Hitec 795_

Favor the Reefs because it appears quiet. The Hitec seems to have a constant noise which I don't like. Savox I've seen used alot but unsure if it's as good as the Reefs.

All are difficult to find here in Alberta. Or so it seems thus far. Also alot more money then they are in the US.

I’ve been using 3brothers G13, Holmes Hobbies and JX (yes, the Chinese ones) and had no problem at all.

 

[BigBlock454]

Savox seemed like the only Servos readily available nearby so I called Savox and asked them directly which to use for my application. They recommended a Savox 1283. I have purchased and installed it. Night and day difference to the stock servo. I do believe it could use an external BEC but I may milk it until I purchase the Mamba X.